Best Peanut Butter Cookies in Columbus, OH

Peanut butter cookies are a classic. Expect soft and chewy home-baked goodness - don’t worry, we deliver. Our specialty peanut butter cookies will quickly become your favorite sweet treat.

Our peanut butter cookies are homemade, soft, and chewy, so if you love creamy peanut butter, these are definitely up your alley. There isn’t a better peanut butter cookie out there. Trust us—we’ve looked! 

Comes as an order of a dozen peanut butter cookies (12 cookies). 

Order Minimum

Peanut butter cookies come in a box by the dozen. Must order a minimum of a dozen cookies. 

Order Processing 

For FREE porch pickup, your order will be ready to pick up approximately within 24 hours after your order is placed.

For local delivery, you will receive your order in 1-2 days after your order is placed.

For nationwide shipping, you will receive your order in 2-3 days after your order has been confirmed as shipped.

Got questions about our brownie & cookie delivery process? Check out our FAQs!