Impress your guests one brownie at a time.
Tired of being chained to your oven hours before guests arrive? Sick of the same old box brownies resurfacing for every family gathering? It’s time to Ditch the Mix!
Shop The Best Brownies You Will Ever Have (In Your Life!)
-
DTM Fan Favorite
Variety Brownie Box
Regular price From $38.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per -
Best Seller
The Buckeye Fan Brownie
Regular price From $21.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per -
DTM Fan Favorite
Brownie Beaus
Regular price $10.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per -
New Arrival
OMG V! Vegan Fudge Brownie
Regular price From $47.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per
EXPLORE ALL SWEET TREATS
-
Custom & Special
We accept custom requests for events and special occasions. Think dessert table...
What Our Customers Say
“I loved that the brownies were delicious, beautifully presented and packaged and marked discreetly for my gluten-free guests. They arrived by delivery on time. I've always had a great experience with Ditch the Mix!” - Brittany S.
Hi, I'm Miranda
Welcome to Ditch the Mix, where every brownie and cookie is made with love and from scratch—just like grandma used to bake. I’m here to bring you the BEST homemade treats you’ll ever have, straight from my home kitchen to your door. It’s time to Ditch the Mix and get your homemade fix!
Why Choose Ditch the Mix for Your Dessert Needs?
- Black-Owned, Woman-Owned Bakery: Proudly based in Columbus, Ohio, we bring you the BEST brownies and cookies you’ll ever have (in your life)—no contest!
- From Scratch, Every Time: We don’t mess with box mixes. Every treat is baked from scratch, with real ingredients and love in every bite.
- Dietary Options for All: Whether you're team Classic (ALL the gluten), Gluten Free, Vegan, or Keto—we’ve got something delicious for everyone.
- Generations of Baking Love: Our recipes are inspired by generations of family baking, making every batch extra special.
- Order & Enjoy: Order online 24 hours in advance for local delivery or pickup, or have our homemade goodness shipped right to your door.
Best Brownies for Work Parties
Your team has been working hard—they deserve a brownie break.
Dessert Catering
From weddings to baby showers, corporate events to graduations—our dessert catering makes every occasion sweeter.
Perfect Homemade Gifts
From celebrations to life's tougher moments, there’s not much a little homemade treat can’t solve.
Hands Down Best Desserts In Columbus: FAQs
-
How long do your brownies stay fresh?
Ditch the Mix brownies stay the freshest for 3-5 days at room temperature if kept in a sealed, airtight container. If you don't want to indulge in all the goodness at once, eat one now and then freeze the remainder for up to a month.
-
How are your brownies packaged?
Ditch the Mix brownies are packaged in a sealed, high-quality bakery box that looks like a gift. Our brownies come in boxes of 6 brownies (minimum) up to 12 brownies (maximum). Each brownie comes in an individual baking cup to preserve flavor. Our cookies also come in a sealed, high-quality bakery box and can be ordered by the dozen.
-
Can your brownies be reheated?
YES! Ditch the Mix brownies are chewy and fudgy (ahem, great as is!), but if you want them to be like "fresh out of the oven" again, reheat them for no more than 10-15 seconds in the microwave. DO NOT RE-BAKE!
Another Raving Review
“I liked that there were regular and gluten-free cookies. I bought it for my workplace event and it was liked by all.”
-Leslie O.